Standard

'I wouldn't want to be the animal in use nor the patient in need' : The role of issue familiarity in students' socioscientific argumentation. / Garrecht, Carola; Reiss, Michael J.; Harms, Ute.

In: International Journal of Science Education, 11.07.2021.

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

Harvard

APA

Vancouver

Author

Garrecht, Carola ; Reiss, Michael J. ; Harms, Ute. / 'I wouldn't want to be the animal in use nor the patient in need' : The role of issue familiarity in students' socioscientific argumentation. In: International Journal of Science Education. 2021.

BibTeX

@article{39207198b65a4a3cb5114ba1ff24d5f8,
title = "'I wouldn't want to be the animal in use nor the patient in need': The role of issue familiarity in students' socioscientific argumentation",
abstract = "Students{\textquoteright} argumentation skills are considered a central tool to contribute to scientific controversies in the science classroom. Scientific controversies of social relevance (socioscientific issues; SSI) are subject to multiple viewpoints that are often rooted in diverse disciplines. However, the relationship between issue familiarity and students{\textquoteright} multidisciplinary argumentation is still a matter under discussion. This study: (1) explores whether the selection of a particular issue (animal testing) enables students{\textquoteright} engagement in multidisciplinary argumentation without additional issue familiarisation, i.e., using only their existing knowledge; and (2) clarifies the relationship between increased issue familiarity and students{\textquoteright} multidisciplinary argumentation. One hundred and sixty three ninth and tenth graders participated in this study, of whom one hundred and six took part in a teaching unit to familiarise themselves with the issue of animal testing. The study{\textquoteright}s results demonstrate that animal testing constitutes an effective issue to engage students with the complexity of SSI without requiring more than basic familiarity prior to engagement. The results further demonstrate that increased issue familiarity can enhance the overall diversity of discipline-related arguments amongst students; however, not all disciplines were enhanced equally. The findings suggest that more instructional guidance seems to be needed to assist students in broadening their arguments.",
keywords = "Domain-specific learning in kindergarten and school, Socioscientific issues, argumentation, scientific literacy",
author = "Carola Garrecht and Reiss, {Michael J.} and Ute Harms",
year = "2021",
month = jul,
day = "11",
language = "English",
journal = "International Journal of Science Education",
issn = "0950-0693",
publisher = "Routledge",

}

RIS

TY - JOUR

T1 - 'I wouldn't want to be the animal in use nor the patient in need'

T2 - The role of issue familiarity in students' socioscientific argumentation

AU - Garrecht, Carola

AU - Reiss, Michael J.

AU - Harms, Ute

PY - 2021/7/11

Y1 - 2021/7/11

N2 - Students’ argumentation skills are considered a central tool to contribute to scientific controversies in the science classroom. Scientific controversies of social relevance (socioscientific issues; SSI) are subject to multiple viewpoints that are often rooted in diverse disciplines. However, the relationship between issue familiarity and students’ multidisciplinary argumentation is still a matter under discussion. This study: (1) explores whether the selection of a particular issue (animal testing) enables students’ engagement in multidisciplinary argumentation without additional issue familiarisation, i.e., using only their existing knowledge; and (2) clarifies the relationship between increased issue familiarity and students’ multidisciplinary argumentation. One hundred and sixty three ninth and tenth graders participated in this study, of whom one hundred and six took part in a teaching unit to familiarise themselves with the issue of animal testing. The study’s results demonstrate that animal testing constitutes an effective issue to engage students with the complexity of SSI without requiring more than basic familiarity prior to engagement. The results further demonstrate that increased issue familiarity can enhance the overall diversity of discipline-related arguments amongst students; however, not all disciplines were enhanced equally. The findings suggest that more instructional guidance seems to be needed to assist students in broadening their arguments.

AB - Students’ argumentation skills are considered a central tool to contribute to scientific controversies in the science classroom. Scientific controversies of social relevance (socioscientific issues; SSI) are subject to multiple viewpoints that are often rooted in diverse disciplines. However, the relationship between issue familiarity and students’ multidisciplinary argumentation is still a matter under discussion. This study: (1) explores whether the selection of a particular issue (animal testing) enables students’ engagement in multidisciplinary argumentation without additional issue familiarisation, i.e., using only their existing knowledge; and (2) clarifies the relationship between increased issue familiarity and students’ multidisciplinary argumentation. One hundred and sixty three ninth and tenth graders participated in this study, of whom one hundred and six took part in a teaching unit to familiarise themselves with the issue of animal testing. The study’s results demonstrate that animal testing constitutes an effective issue to engage students with the complexity of SSI without requiring more than basic familiarity prior to engagement. The results further demonstrate that increased issue familiarity can enhance the overall diversity of discipline-related arguments amongst students; however, not all disciplines were enhanced equally. The findings suggest that more instructional guidance seems to be needed to assist students in broadening their arguments.

KW - Domain-specific learning in kindergarten and school

KW - Socioscientific issues

KW - argumentation

KW - scientific literacy

M3 - Journal article

JO - International Journal of Science Education

JF - International Journal of Science Education

SN - 0950-0693

ER -

ID: 1424528